Showing 1 - 36 of 3912Next >
Bacon Cheese
This high-quality, delicious cheese is made from premium milk, collected from small family farms.
00200
$5.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Blueberry Cheddar Loaf
Smooth and mellow white cheddar is mixed with blueberries, making Troyer® Blueberry Cheddar Cheese a fruity, flavorful dessert cheese.
00226
$10.69 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head 3 Pepper Co-Jack
Showcasing the intense flavor of peppers that thrive in Brazil's lush landscape, Boar's Head Bold 3 Pepper Colby Jack Cheese evokes the vibrant colors and rhythms from south of the equator. This blend of mellow Colby Jack cheese with zesty red and green jalapeños, smoky chipotles and fiery green and orange habanero peppers is a flavor voyage for the adventurous at heart.

Milk Source: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States (Wisconsin)
Cheese Type: Semi-soft

Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added
00248
$9.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Creamy Havarti
Made in the traditional Scandinavian manner, this mild cheese has a semi-soft texture and distinctively rich, buttery taste. Cream Havarti balances beautifully with slices of savory Boar’s Head Virginia Ham on crusty bread, adds creaminess to a fruit and cheese platter and melts into a flavorful sauce.

Milk Source: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States (Wisconsin)
Cheese Type: Semi-soft

Also available as Cream Havarti Cheese with Dill and Cream Havarti Cheese with Jalapeño.

Feingold® Food List - Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00256
$9.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Havarti Dill
A double crème classic made in the traditional Danish style. Boar’s Head Cream Havarti with Dill is a Wisconsin-made cheese that has an incredibly creamy texture with a rich buttery taste and the delicate flavor of Dill.

Milk Source: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States (Wisconsin)
Cheese Type: Semi-soft

Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00258
$7.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Imported Swiss Cheese
Crafted with milk from cows not treated with rBST* growth hormone, Boar's Head Simplicity All Natural* Imported Swiss Cheese is bold and nutty with earthy notes and is naturally low in sodium. This incredibly balanced Swiss Cheese import is crafted in the authentic Alpine tradition under the watchful supervision of Käse Meisters.

Country of Origin: Switzerland

Gluten Free - Lactose Free - Lower Sodium - No Caramel Color -


*No significant difference has been shown between milk from rBST treated and untreated cows.
*No Artificial Ingredients, Minimally Processed
00281
$7.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Smoked Gouda
A unique blend of buttery Gouda and mild cheddar. Boar's Head Smoked Gouda Cheese is naturally smoked with hickory and hardwoods, for a cheese with subtle smoky notes and a rich, creamy flavor.

Milk Source: Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States

Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00254
$7.29 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Vermont White Cheddar
Made with milk sourced from regional family farms, this cheese has a pleasantly mild, rich flavor and smooth, creamy texture. Boar's Head Vermont Cheddar Cheese is aged for three months to achieve the classic Cheddar taste.

Country of Origin: United States (Vermont)
Available in white or yellow.

Gluten Free - Lactose Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00228
$6.29 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Vermont Yellow Cheddar
Made with milk sourced from regional family farms, this cheese has a pleasantly mild, rich flavor and smooth, creamy texture. Boar's Head Vermont Cheddar Cheese is aged for three months to achieve the classic Cheddar taste.

Available in yellow or white.

Gluten Free - Lactose Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added
00229
$8.29 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head White  American Loaf
Crafted from a hand-selected blend of rich, savory Cheddars, this all-American cheese has a smooth, creamy texture and pleasantly mild taste. Boar's Head American Cheese is an amazingly meltable, flavorful classic.

Milk Source: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States
Available in white and yellow.

Feingold® Food List - Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00207
$6.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Wisconsin Cheddar, Black Wax
Selected by Cheese Graders at the peak of flavor, this cheese has an unmistakably sharp taste with a balanced finish. Boar's Head Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese is aged for nine months to produce its distinctive flavor and smooth texture.

Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added
00227
$9.19 / lb This item is not available online.
Boar's Head Yellow  American Loaf
Crafted from a hand-selected blend of rich, savory Cheddars, this all-American cheese has a smooth, creamy texture and pleasantly mild taste. Boar's Head American Cheese is an amazingly meltable, flavorful classic.

Milk Source: Pasteurized Cow's Milk
Country of Origin: United States
Available in white and yellow.

Feingold® Food List - Gluten Free - No Caramel Color - No MSG Added - Premium Vegetarian Products
00208
$6.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Butter Cheese
Mild, rich, & buttery flavor is the taste of this Guggisberg signature cheese. It melts well and is great for cooking!
00218
$6.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Cheddar, Habanero & Jalapeno
This one packs quite a kick! Liven up your taste buds with this dynamic combination of aged cheddar, habanero and jalapeño peppers. Shred and melt this spicy treat over grilled chicken breasts, in quesadillas or as a zesty sauce for your favorite Mexican dishes.
00222
$9.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Co-Jack
Produced from a mixture of Colby and Monterey Jack. It has a mild to mellow flavor and is semi-hard in texture. A very popular choice at Yoder's.
00240
$4.69 / lb This item is not available online.
Colby Cheese
Colby originated in Wisconsin in 1874. Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby is softer and has a more open texture and high-moisture content.
00242
$4.69 / lb This item is not available online.
Daisy Cheddar
Aged Cheddar has a rich flavor and slightly tangy bite. Makes a wonderful gift or addition to the dinner table. Find this in wedges on our deli case.
00220
$7.19 / lb This item is not available online.
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Aged for 1-2 years, New York State Cheddar is too sharp to slice! Find it in chunks in our cooler.
00221
$8.29 / lb This item is not available online.
Garden Vegetable Yogurt
A great snacking cheese, this healthy yogurt cheese is wonderful alongside your favorite recipes.

All Natural - Lactose Free - Low Sodium
00263
$7.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Garlic Cheese
A creamy cheese with a hint of garlic. Lovely addition to any sandwich, elevates any snack.
00206
$4.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Guggisberg Baby Swiss
The Cheese that Made Guggisberg Famous! Their Original Baby Swiss is delightfully mild and creamy, and loved by all.

Awarded U.S. Grand Champion & #1 Cheese in America.
00287
$5.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Heidi Ann Angel Lace Swiss
A mild swiss with small lacey holes. This swiss melts smoothly and is a wonderful choice for those who cannot have lactose, but love swiss.

All Natural - Low Sodium - Lactose Free
00284
$7.59 / lb This item is not available online.
Horseradish Cheese
A cheese for horseradish lovers. You can't go wrong with this smooth, tasty add-on.
00203
$5.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Jumping Jack Cheese
A mix of Colby and Monterey Jack, this cheese will have your mouth jumping from the jalapeno peppers it contains! The spiciness is not for the faint of mouth. Come see if you can handle the heat!
00244
$4.69 / lb This item is not available online.
Mozzarella Cheese
Smooth mozzarella at its best! A mild, creamy flavor to please any palate. Used on our popular Pizza Sandwich!
00272
$4.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Muenster
Soft, creamy, and melty is the best way to describe Muenster cheese. You can never go wrong with some in your fridge.
00274
$4.49 / lb This item is not available online.
Pepper Jack Cheese
Need to get a spicy verison of your favorite Monterey Jack? Look no further! Pepper-Jack serves as a heated verison, and is a well-known sandwich cheese.
00246
$4.69 / lb This item is not available online.
Provolone
Smooth and originated in Italy, this cheese is full of protien and calcium! Goes well on sandwiches, platters, and snacks.
00278
$4.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Sharp Cheddar Cheese
If you've had a Yoder's Cafe sandwich with cheddar on it, then you've tasted this cheese! A classic cheddar that brings your tastebuds to life, Thumann's sharp cheddar is one of our popular deli choices!

Certified Gluten-Free - Feingold ® Program - Aged Over 6 Months
00224
$7.29 / lb This item is not available online.
Stella Blue Cheese
Salads, sauces, steaks, burgers, Buffalo wings... the opportunities are endless! Get a wedge of easy-to-crumble blue cheese from our cooler today!
00212
$6.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Super Sharp Cheddar
Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar is an award winning Canadian cheddar cheese made in Quebec, cured in Lancaster County, PA.. This cheese is cured a minimum of three years and is only sold when the flavor meets the producers' standards. The actual age of this cheddar will range between three and four years and occasionally longer. On rare occasions this cheddar has been known for being aged up to fifteen and even twenty years!
00225
$13.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Swiss Cheese
Award winning, sweet and nutty flavored Cheese with distinctive eyes (holes). This is what Pearl Valley famous for! Their 2014 World Championship Cheese Contest Gold Medal Winner. Their most popular cheese, and our favorite!

This all natural cheese is made from milk that is rBst Free.*

*The FDA has stated that there is no significant difference between milk from rBST-treated and untreated cows.

Aged Over 60 Days
00280
$5.99 / lb This item is not available online.
Walnut Creek Farmers Cheese
Farmers Cheese is a wonderful, nutritious choice for snacking. It slices and melts well, making it a perfect candidate for sandwiches, gourmet pizzas, casseroles and cheeseburgers. A nice all-occasion cheese, it is enjoyed by kids and adults alike.
00261
$5.19 / lb This item is not available online.
Showing 1 - 36 of 3912Next >